HORRIFIC CRUELTY IN KEADY: AENEAS CARRAGHER AND WAYNE SMYTH SENTENCED FOR ANIMAL ABUSE

On Monday, March 11, 2024, a disturbing case of animal cruelty was brought to light involving local residents Aeneas Carragher and Wayne Smyth, both of whom faced convictions related to the suffering of a dairy cow. Carragher, a farmer residing at 85 Skerriff Road, Cullyhanna, Newry BT35 0JW, and Smyth, an animal transporter from Annvale Gardens, Keady, Armagh BT60 2RS, were found guilty of causing unnecessary suffering to a vulnerable animal.

The incident in question dates back to February 13, 2023, when the case was brought before authorities following a routine inspection at an abattoir. A Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) Official Veterinarian (OV) examined a cow that had been presented for slaughter by Smyth on behalf of Carragher. The veterinarian’s assessment revealed a deeply troubling state of health in the animal.

The cow was notably emaciated, with her body condition so poor that her ribs and spinal processes were prominently visible. She was shivering and appeared extremely weak. An attempt was made by a lairage worker to make the cow walk, but she immediately collapsed and fell in the pen, indicating her severe physical distress.

The veterinarian conducted an ante-mortem examination on the recumbent animal. The findings confirmed that the cow was in a dire state of health, with a body condition score estimated at “1” or less, signifying extreme emaciation. The veterinarian concluded that the animal was unfit for transport due to her weakened condition.

In a humane response to her suffering, the veterinarian ordered the cow to be humanely destroyed at the scene, preventing any further pain or distress. The professional opinion was clear: the cow’s condition was so poor that her transportation was not only unnecessary but also caused her additional suffering. This act of neglect and cruelty has sparked outrage within the community and highlights ongoing concerns about animal welfare standards in the region.

Both Carragher and Smyth were subsequently convicted of their roles in this case. Carragher was fined £500 along with an additional £15 offender levy, while Smyth received the same financial penalties. Their convictions serve as a stark reminder of the importance of adhering to animal welfare laws and the consequences of neglecting the suffering of vulnerable animals.